# BrightPay vs Xero Payroll for holiday pay: how each handles leave and holiday pay

URL: https://holidaypay.co.uk/guides/brightpay-vs-xero-payroll-holiday-pay
Updated: 2026-11-16

> How BrightPay and Xero Payroll handle annual leave and holiday pay, from their own public pages: accrual, leave requests, Xero journals and which fits.

BrightPay is a separate payroll product that sends payroll journals into Xero's accounting, while Xero Payroll runs payroll inside Xero itself. BrightPay's documentation says it tracks leave entitlement but the user enters the holiday pay amount, whereas Xero says its payroll handles the 52-week average for irregular hours. Holiday Pay Check works only with Xero Payroll.

## Key points

- **BrightPay** offers six annual leave entitlement methods, including two for irregular hours that accrue 12.07% of hours entered per pay period.
- BrightPay's 2025-26 documentation says the holiday pay amount "is not automatically calculated by BrightPay" and "must be entered manually by the user".
- BrightPay connects to Xero by sending a payroll journal to Xero accounting, using your chart of accounts. It does not use Xero Payroll.
- **Xero Payroll** lists "Automatic calculation of tax, pensions and leave" on its features page, and a Xero guide says the 52-week average and rolled-up pay for irregular hours are handled for you.
- Xero has no UK report that checks each past holiday against the 52-week average with workings. A request for one was answered by Xero on 27 November 2025 as "not a feature we have planned".
- **Holiday Pay Check** only works with Xero Payroll. If you run payroll in BrightPay, it is not for you.

Everything said about BrightPay and Xero on this page comes from their own public websites, help pages and Xero App Store listings, checked on 16 November 2026. Where we could not find something, we say it is not stated. Prices depend on plan and staff numbers and change often, so check their own pricing pages; BrightPay's cloud price calculator is listed in the sources.

## How BrightPay handles annual leave and holiday pay

BrightPay comes in three versions, according to its product comparison page: BrightPay desktop, desktop plus BrightPay Connect, and BrightPay Cloud. The same page says BrightPay for Mac will not be available from tax year 2025/26, so the desktop version is for Windows.

### Leave entitlement

BrightPay's documentation for 2025-26 lists six ways to set up annual leave entitlement:

1. a set number of annual leave days, without recognising time worked;
2. accrued by number of working days, using the statutory entitlement as the basis (for example 3 days a week gives 3 × 5.6 = 16.8 days);
3. accrued by hours worked for set hours per day, applying 12.07% to hours worked, excluding overtime;
4. the same, including overtime;
5. accrued by hours worked for irregular hours, based on the hours entered per pay period, excluding overtime;
6. the same, including overtime.

The same page notes that in some circumstances, particularly for part-year workers or zero-hour contracts, the 12.07% calculation "may be unreliable", and refers users to HMRC guidance and professional advice.

Leave is recorded on the employee's calendar in BrightPay, and BrightPay says it "will keep a track of an employee's annual leave entitlement".

### Holiday pay amount

BrightPay's "Processing Holiday Pay" page (2025-26 documentation) says the holiday pay amount due to an employee "is not automatically calculated by BrightPay" and "must be entered manually by the user". You add a "Holiday Pay" item under Additions and Deductions and enter the amount. That means whoever runs payroll works out the 52-week average, or whatever rate applies, outside BrightPay. We could not find the 2026-27 version of this page, so check BrightPay's current documentation.

Whether BrightPay supports rolled-up holiday pay as a separate payslip line is not stated on the pages we could access.

### Leave requests and employee portal

BrightPay's product comparison page says employee leave requests and an employee self-service portal are available with Desktop plus Connect and with BrightPay Cloud, not with Desktop alone. Employees can view colleagues' leave on the calendar in those versions, and an annual leave report is listed for all versions.

### Xero integration

BrightPay's Xero page and its Xero App Store listing say BrightPay retrieves your nominal ledger accounts from Xero, lets you map each payroll item to an account, and sends the payroll journal to Xero, by API or as a file. The listing describes the data flow as "Accounts shared from Xero to BrightPay" and "Journals shared from BrightPay to Xero". The integration is with Xero accounting; neither page mentions Xero Payroll.

## How Xero Payroll handles annual leave and holiday pay

Xero Payroll is part of Xero. Xero's Xero Me page says Xero Me works with the Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate plans, and that all of these include payroll.

What Xero says on its own pages:

- Its payroll features page lists "Automatic calculation of tax, pensions and leave". Its separate line, "Add employee details and dates for Xero to calculate statutory leave and pay", sits under maternity, paternity, adoption, shared parental, sick and bereavement leave and pay, not annual leave.
- Employees can check leave balances and submit leave requests through Xero Me, and managers with assigned access can review and approve leave requests.
- Xero "automatically generates the payroll journal when posting a pay run".
- A Xero guide on summer holiday pay, published 3 September 2026, says: "Holiday pay calculations, including the 52-week average and rolled-up pay for irregular hours, are handled for you."

What Xero's product ideas forum shows (Xero's own replies):

- "UK Payroll - Leave Balances Report": Xero replied on 27 November 2025 that it "isn't on our immediate roadmap".
- "Run a report to calculate holiday pay based on a 52 week average": Xero replied on 27 November 2025 that it is "not a feature we have planned".
- Xero UK shows each employee's leave balance on their leave tab and payslips, and has a Leave Requests report (released 8 May 2024), which Xero says "is not the equivalent of the Leave Balances report".

So Xero says it handles holiday pay in pay runs, but it does not offer a report that looks back at each holiday and checks it against the 52-week average with the workings. Our guide to [Xero holiday pay](/guides/xero-holiday-pay) covers this in more detail.

## Comparison table

| | BrightPay | Xero Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Separate payroll software (Windows desktop, desktop plus Connect, cloud) | Payroll inside Xero |
| Connection to Xero accounting | Sends payroll journal to Xero (API or file) | Generates its own payroll journal when a pay run is posted |
| Leave entitlement methods | Six, including 12.07% hourly accrual for irregular hours | Not set out on its features page, which lists "Automatic calculation of tax, pensions and leave" |
| Holiday pay amount | Not calculated automatically; entered manually (2025-26 docs) | Xero says the 52-week average and rolled-up pay for irregular hours are handled for you |
| Rolled-up holiday pay | Not stated on the pages we could access | Xero guide says it is handled for irregular hours |
| Report checking past holidays against the 52-week average | Not stated on their website | No; idea answered "not a feature we have planned" (27 Nov 2025) |
| Employee leave requests | Desktop plus Connect and Cloud | Xero Me, with manager approval |
| Leave balances shown to staff | Not stated on its comparison page | Xero Me; also on payslips |
| Annual leave report | Listed for all versions | Leave Requests report; no UK Leave Balances report |
| Pricing basis | Desktop per tax year; Connect monthly extra; Cloud by employers and employees, annual discount | Included in Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate plans |
| Xero App Store rating | 4.6 out of 5 from 8 reviews (listing, 16 Nov 2026) | Not applicable (Xero's own product) |
| Works with Holiday Pay Check | No | Yes |

## When BrightPay may suit you better

From what BrightPay publishes, it may be the better fit if:

- you want a choice of desktop or cloud payroll;
- you want several entitlement methods, including hours-based accrual that can include or exclude overtime;
- you have a larger workforce (its comparison page says desktop employee numbers depend on the licence, up to unlimited subject to a fair usage cap of 5,000, and Cloud supports up to 300 employees per employer);
- you are happy to work out holiday pay amounts yourself and enter them.

## When Xero Payroll may suit you better

From what Xero publishes, it may be the better fit if:

- you already use Xero accounting on a plan that includes payroll and want one system;
- you want Xero to calculate leave and holiday pay in the pay run;
- staff use Xero Me for payslips, leave balances and leave requests.

## Where Holiday Pay Check fits

Holiday Pay Check works only with Xero Payroll. It connects read-only, reads employees, pay runs, payslips and leave, and never edits anything in Xero. For each holiday taken, it works out the 52-week average, compares it with what was paid, marks possible underpayments "Review" and shows the workings. A person decides. It also keeps a dated six-year record for each employee.

It does not work with BrightPay. BrightPay sends journals to Xero accounting, not payslips or leave, so Holiday Pay Check would have no pay data to read. If you use BrightPay, the checks in our [52-week average guide](/guides/52-week-average-holiday-pay) can be done by hand or in a spreadsheet from BrightPay's own reports.

### Example: what a holiday check looks at

These figures are made up to show the arithmetic.

An irregular-hours worker earned £18,200.00 in their previous 52 paid weeks. The 52-week average is £18,200.00 ÷ 52 = £350.00 a week. Their holiday week was paid at £315.00. The difference is £350.00 minus £315.00 = £35.00.

In BrightPay, someone would enter the holiday pay amount, so the check is whether the amount entered matched the average. In Xero Payroll, the check is whether the pay run produced the right figure for that worker. In both cases, a gap like £35.00 is worth a person reviewing; it is not automatically an underpayment. The free [holiday pay calculator](/calculator) works through one holiday.

### Holiday Pay Check prices

A free check shows how many holidays need review. After that it is £12 a month for up to 15 staff, £24 up to 50 and £49 up to 150. Yearly billing gives 2 months free, so up to 15 staff costs £12 × 10 = £120 a year. Holiday Pay Check is in early access and has no customer reviews yet. See [pricing](/pricing) and [how it works](/how-it-works).

## Questions to ask before choosing payroll

1. **Do you have irregular-hours or part-year staff?** GOV.UK says their holiday pay is the average from the previous 52 paid weeks, looking back no more than 104 weeks.
2. **Who will work out holiday pay amounts?** In BrightPay's documentation, the user enters them.
3. **Do staff need to request leave and see balances?** Check which BrightPay version you need, or whether your Xero plan includes Xero Me.
4. **How will you keep six-year records?** From 6 April 2026, GOV.UK says employers must keep records of annual leave and holiday pay for at least six years.
5. **Do you want a separate check of past holidays?** Neither website shows one built in.

This page compares what each company publishes. It is not legal advice. For a specific worker's holiday pay, contact Acas or your payroll provider.

## Sources

- BrightPay homepage, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/
- BrightPay, Product comparison, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/pages/product-comparison/
- BrightPay documentation 2025-26, Annual leave entitlement methods, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/docs/25-26/annual-leave/annual-leave-entitlement-methods-in-brightpay/
- BrightPay documentation 2025-26, Recording an employee's annual leave, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/docs/25-26/annual-leave/recording-an-employee-s-annual-leave/
- BrightPay documentation 2025-26, Processing holiday pay, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/docs/25-26/annual-leave/processing-holiday-pay/
- BrightPay, Journal integration with Xero, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.brightpay.co.uk/pages/journal-integration-xero
- BrightPay Cloud price calculator, accessed 16 November 2026: https://brightsg.com/en-gb/brightpay-in-the-cloud-calculator
- Xero App Store, BrightPay, accessed 16 November 2026: https://apps.xero.com/uk/app/brightpay
- Xero, Payroll features, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.xero.com/uk/accounting-software/payroll/features/
- Xero, Xero Me, accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.xero.com/uk/xero-me/
- Xero, Summer holiday pay guide (published 3 September 2026), accessed 16 November 2026: https://www.xero.com/uk/guides/summer-holiday-pay-staff/
- Xero product ideas, UK Payroll Leave Balances Report: https://productideas.xero.com/forums/967118-payroll-expenses/suggestions/45925522
- Xero product ideas, Run a report to calculate holiday pay based on a 52 week average: https://productideas.xero.com/forums/967118-payroll-expenses/suggestions/45241594
- GOV.UK, Holiday entitlement: Holiday pay: https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights/holiday-pay
- Legislation.gov.uk, Employment Rights Act 2025, section 35: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2025/36/section/35

## Questions

### Does BrightPay calculate holiday pay automatically?

BrightPay's 2025-26 documentation says the holiday pay amount due to an employee is not automatically calculated by BrightPay and must be entered manually by the user. BrightPay does track leave entitlement, including methods that accrue 12.07% of hours worked.

### Does Xero Payroll calculate holiday pay?

Xero's payroll features page lists "Automatic calculation of tax, pensions and leave", and a Xero guide dated 3 September 2026 says the 52-week average and rolled-up pay for irregular hours are handled for you. Xero does not have a report that checks each past holiday against the 52-week average with workings.

### Does BrightPay integrate with Xero?

Yes, with Xero's accounting side. BrightPay retrieves your chart of accounts from Xero, you map payroll items to nominal accounts, and BrightPay sends the payroll journal to Xero. Its Xero App Store listing says accounts are shared from Xero to BrightPay and journals from BrightPay to Xero.

### Can I use Holiday Pay Check with BrightPay?

No. Holiday Pay Check reads pay runs, payslips and leave from Xero Payroll. BrightPay sends journals to Xero accounting, not payslips, so there is nothing in Xero Payroll for Holiday Pay Check to read.

### Which is better for holiday pay, BrightPay or Xero Payroll?

It depends on your set-up. BrightPay offers several leave entitlement methods, desktop and cloud versions and an employee portal with leave requests. Xero Payroll sits inside your Xero subscription and posts its own journal. Neither public website shows a report that checks each past holiday against the 52-week average.
